Carnegie Pizza was close to our hotel and decided to try it out. The pizza is pretty good. The salad was lacking, especially for the price. Overall I would recommend Carnegie Pizza if you are in a hurry or in the area. However, since there are so many other pizzerias around, I would try another one first before going back if given the option.

Line isn't too crazy, like Joe's pizza. Everyone is nice and quick. They put the pizza you select in the oven, and while it's warming up, you can go pay. They have a lot of different flavors, not just basic cheese and sausage. Personally, I got a slice of sweet chili chicken and a slice of pepperoni & jalapeño. Both slices were tasty. If you get the triangle slices, they are large and wide. The square cut is more condensed and bite sized. The shop also offers chicken rolls, garlic knots and bottled drinks. Price wasn't too crazy, from what I can remember. There are places to eat inside. I think it's mostly bar style seating with a few booths. Relatively quiet vibe for NYC.

Overall, solid slices! I did like the cheese and sauce, the sauce had especially good flavor. But seriously, I think they need to improve their reheat strategy lol. If you put a cheese slice and a Sicilian in the oven to reheat, you SHOULD take the cheese slice out first... because it's thinner (obviously). My Sicilian was scrumptious but my cheese slice was too crispy, the sauce dried out... it was overcooked. Attention to details gets 5s, ya know? Id come back if I was in the area though, because I'm a fat ass

Situated right next to the flagship Joes pizza but this is definitely better because it is less crowded and also their pizzas were so good. You don't have to wait on the line and you get your pizza fresh from the oven. Margherita and Vodka pizza were my fav. Has a lot of room to dine-in.

Large, yummy slices of thin crust pizza that hit the spot! Operation hour is great as we are still trying to adjust to eastern standard time. Open past midnight!

Purchased my lunch at Carnegie Pizza and was pleasantly surprised. The pizzeria is clean, has plenty of food options, a quick serving staff, nice wall photos/decor, and comfortable seating areas. I had an eggplant slice, that came with garlic, peeled tomatoes, and placed on a thin crispy slice. Each bite was thoroughly enjoyed and I will definitely return to enjoy this slice, again.

I don't know why this place doesn't have a line down the block (like a very hyped up spot nearby) but we decided to try it after seeing the other line, and I'm so glad we did! This pizza was damn good! We tried a thin NY style pepperoni and sausage, a thick square slice with pepperoni, and a chicken with a sweet chili sauce. The two pepperoni slices were very different, but both delicious. The sauces even seemed to be different, with a bit more richness and kick on the square slice. The sweet chili chicken was the star though. Not a traditional pizza flavor wise, but absolutely to die for.

This pizza was amazing and I'm not just saying that bc it was right next to my hotel, but eating pizza and garlic knots in bed is the best way to end a NYC tourist day. Unless you dont like garlic, which, you do you. The thick pizza was especially great. We don't have any place local that does pepperoni quite like that, and the white cheese pizza was top notch. They also have seating for 2-3 groups inside and picnic tables outside on the sidewalk! We went here four nights in a row, sorry not sorry, and the line was never long and the food was always great.

Need a late night snack after walking around Time Square? This place was it! My mom and I were looking for some good pizza and surprisingly there was no wait here. The pizza was super good and quickly served to us. Of course got a cheese pizza can't go wrong with that. I also got a slice of Buffalo Chicken and didn't know how it would be but it was delish. The chicken was nicely breaded and juicy. My mom got a cheese and a pepperoni, the only thing I can say about this is the pepperoni was okay. I personally like it a bit crispier but the pizza was good! Also the sauce they use does have a little kick to it. So if you're not into spicey I'd skip. Like most NY spots, it was pretty tight buuuuut did have a lot of stand up spots. There were a few table in the back. Which we did sit, and some spots you could just share the table. Place was super clean and the people working were super nice.

It was fresh slices of pizza. Located near the Nederlander Theater, it was open when the show let out so we headed there. I'm not Dave Portnoy from Bar Stool Sports, but I suspect this pizza is average. But they got it to us quickly and seemed nice about it.